Diocese of Rockville Centre

Home
Only Followers Should Lead Print E-mail
Thursday, 19 November 2009 16:05

Rev. Robert Ketcham

 After gracing us with his 2000 hit, It’s my Life, in which he boasted, “I aint gonna live forever”, Jon Bon Jovi has released another expression of his poetic sterility called, We Weren’t Born to Follow, and it has me thinking.  Rather, it has me somewhat unsettled since it only perpetuates the deception of young men who may have otherwise considered it virtuous to follow Christ as a priest; the lyrics of this new song suggest that obedience is something unnatural and that following a greater good is not virtuous. 

I may be making too much of this one song and its impact on the youth, especially since Jon Bon Jovi (now 47) no longer sings on their behalf.  However, I would like to reflect not on what the song purport to say, but what it actually says.  

The chorus of the song continues:

“We weren’t born to follow;
come on and get up off your knees.
When life is a bitter pill to swallow,
 you gotta hold on to what you believe.”

It’s full of dangerous contradictions that can paralyze us while bringing us to think ourselves less than admirable for being disciples of Jesus, since discipleship requires that we follow, something that Bon Jovi claims we weren’t born to do.    

follow-me.jpgOf course, however, his intention is not really to discourage people from following at all, but rather to compel them to follow him.  The expression, “come on”, is a dead giveaway that it is he who wants followers, and the melody, at the expense of beauty, is just another earworm, impossible to forget and easy to follow.   

And I’m sorry Mr. Bon Jovi, but the idea of swallowing the “bitter pill” of circumstance only serves to remind me of drinking the Robitussin not because I wanted to, but because it was right and good to follow my mother’s advice. 

Even the image of “[holding] on to what you believe” denotes the high virtue of being led by something greater – something, ironically enough, worth following.      

Finally, the idea of not being “born to follow” leaves me wondering just how long a child might, in such a case, survive without following his mother to her breast, or his father to the surface of the pool after his first dive.     

And all of this idealistic gas (to borrow an expression from C.S. Lewis) sits nestled between the most obviously problematic line of all, namely, “get up off your knees”.  Who would dare interrupt a man in prayer?  It would be as precarious as suggesting to a child that the streets are as good a place as any to play. 

The lyrics of this song are the words of a proud and apparently unsatisfied band of men who are not to be considered wise since they seem not to understand that the best   leaders are always also the best followers.  Good leadership is inseparable from faithful discipleship.

Consider how Jesus is a devout follower of the Divine Will of his Father.  In fact, it is from his obedient sonship that his greatness flows.  To whom did he give himself on the cross if not to his Father?  And to whom did he ascend after his Resurrection?  Everything he does he does for his Father.  He, himself, tells us: “I came down from heaven not to do my own will, but the will of him who sent me” (Jn 6:39).    

And he calls his disciples to this same kind of willingness to follow.  Consider his words to Matthew and to Philip, “Follow me” (Mt 9:9 / Jn 1:43), or those to anyone with ears to hear:

“If any man would come after me, let him deny himself, take up his cross and follow me” (Mk 8:34).  Think also of his reference to his sheep who hear his voice and “follow” him (Jn 10:27), and of Saint John’s vision of the undefiled in Heaven who, even now, “follow the Lamb” (Rev 14:4). 

No, it is not the problem of modern man that he tends too easily to follow; it is quite the opposite; it is his reluctance to follow that holds him back from experiencing the true freedom of belonging to God, and leads to his smug condemnation of those who do so joyfully and unapologetically. 

In contrast to the drivel and balderdash offered by Jon Bon Jovi, listen now to the words of a hymn sung by the boys of The Bamfylde School of Cornwall England at the beginning of each episode of the 1980 BBC television series, To Serve Them All My Days:

Look ahead to a life worth living
full of hope, full of faith, full of cheer
to a life that is made for giving
without stint, without shame, without fear.

Look ahead to the one who leads us
to the Lord who guides our ways.
We shall follow, follow, follow;
we shall follow him all our days.

 

Words such as these beget men capable of real leadership, truly priestly men who are man enough to follow Christ into the wilderness of the cities, into the homes and into the schools.  Words such as these form the soldiers who receive Purple Hearts and the priests who receive Sacred Hearts.  And they become for us living reminders that we were indeed all born to follow, born to follow Jesus.                

 in Jesus and Mary

- fr robert    

Trackback(0)
Comments (5)Add Comment
...
written by a guest, November 22, 2009
Father Rob,

I am wondering if you ever heard the song "Better Days" by The Goo Goo Dolls. You should give it a listen.

Jeannine Maloney
...
written by a guest, November 22, 2009
Yes, Jeannine, I know the song, and I would say that while it may be spiritual and sensitive, it is not enough to truly satisfy the Christian, since the Christian can only be satisified (here on earth) by a sacramental encounter with Christ. I appreciate what songs like "Better Days" try to do, namely whet our appetite for the attributes of God, but they never actually offer us an encounter with him - that is something only the Church can do.

G.K. Chesterton wrote in his book, Orthodoxy, something about how the real damage caused by the Reformation was not the spread of the vices, but the spread of the virtues. And I think that what he meant was now that Christendom was torn open like a bag of coins, people were going to find the coins on the streets and not know where they came from - a big problem for mankind whose ultimate end is not just to have God's coins, but to thank him for them. So I've been starting to think about bands like the Goo Goo Dolls - who use words like "peace", "faith", "trust","prayer" and even "poor child who saved the world" - as spreading the coins, but not telling anyone where they come from.

The problem, of course, is that most modern rock bands in the secular world pretend that these coins of virtue come from them, when in reality "peace", "faith","prayer" and even the "poor child who saved the world" all have their origin in the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church.

Still, knowing this will be of little value unless we actually persevere in tracing these scattered coins of virtue to their source, which is the Mass, and use them to purchase our salvation from the storehouse of his mercy, which is Confession. Only then will these virtues bring better days. And until then, they are just pretty words that sell albums.

- Father Robert
...
written by a guest, November 22, 2009
Boy, did you really over think a nice song. I believe anything, be it song, art, literature or going to Mass that helps us to be better people is a good thing. As a 45 year old adult I can tell you, you will have an easier time getting people to listen to you if you don't bash them over the head with what they are doing wrong. My Grandmother used to say, "Hand them a bouquet and then tell them the bad news." It was good advice. I think that a band spreading a good message even if it doesn't mention God directly is to be commended not condemned. Regular music is far more popular then Christen music to the general population. Better to spread a good message then a bad one, not matter how it get spread. A few weeks ago, the readings talked about one of the Apostles asking Jesus to stop someone from spreading the word. Jesus answered that as long as they were spreading the word it was a good thing.

Respectfully,

Jeannine
...
written by a guest, November 27, 2009
I agree that any message that gets us closer to God's truth is to be commended but when the concept of Christ is left out it will never serve it's true potential. Where we have impressions or imperfect visions of our own heart's desire the "Spirit itself intercedes with inexpressable groanings". I always applaud a good message but they'll be a half-measure if tempered or cut short for social norms or sensibilities.

Joe
Mari
written by Marilyn West, February 03, 2010
I think that part of the meaning of God somehow gets lost in mediocrity and in selling God short by watering down Who He really is. He is more than a message that, while good intentioned, has opted for the more politically correct view of Who and what this God is. As if it isn't enough for God to be faceless, but now He must be hidden and disguised by "well meaning words and good intentions"...sell out. If someone is going to spread a good message, then spread a good message that doesn't omit the truth. Question, if one had to give someone directions to their home, they would obviously give them the street name, but would one leave out a more important piece of information...namely the address number. Hey, it's nice to know what street you live on, but you only really know where they live if you give a complete address which "includes" a bit more info...the number. The fact that most secular music seems a bit more palatable than Christian music is not because of the quality or sound more so than the "choice" to listen to truth or the the worlds view of what they think the truth should be. It's easier to justify ourselves if we don't have to face the truth because Truth means accountability, responsibility and love of others. Today's music throws caution to the wind and sells our children the notion that it's o.k and acceptable to be concerned only with ourselves and that we can be "free" to do as we please and without consequences. I have never heard a song that encourages sex or one night stands and the like talk about the "consequences" of that action. It's all for the moment. But anyway, I'm a 40 year old who knows from my own experience, that our young people also desire the truth...no matter what. No political correctness or feeling like you have to walk on eggshells around them...trust me they appreciate the truth rather than a confusing message and watered down version of it. Some of these "feel good" songs may have a "nice" message, but they have no substance. it's one thing to feel good and be of good cheer, but it's quite another to learn Who we count on for that. Peace and Prayers...Marilyn

Write comment

busy
 

Blog Disclaimer:

"The opinions expressed by the Bloggers and those providing comments are theirs alone, and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Diocese of Rockville Centre. The Diocese of Rockville Centre is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied in the Blog. The Webmaster reserves the right to exclude comments that are deemed to be objectionable or otherwise inappropriate."